And again: Youd think that, if you had a murderer in your student population, youd do something about it. I had long since given up my dream of uniting the Hallows, but I could not resist, could not help taking a closer look . He looked fleetingly like a small boy caught in wrongdoing. Second, in the memory, Morfin pushed the hair out of his dirty face, the better to see [Voldemort], and Harry saw that he wore Marvolos black-stoned ring on his right hand. So, we have proof that before Voldemort visited Morfin, Morfin had the ring. why did harry make ron believe he had added felix felicis to rons juice? . Morfin Gaunt (c. 1900-pre 1996) was a British pure-blood wizard descended from Salazar Slytherin. he realized mundugus had been stealing from sirius' house. But Dumbledore didnt need the memory to establish that Voldemort was wearing the ring at the time because Dumbledore was there, in the school, to see it for himself. He covered up his crimes by altering Morfin's memory, causing him to falsely believe he was the killer. In the summer of 1943, Morfin seemed to not know that he had encountered his half-blood nephew (the son of his 'blood traitor sister' and the 'filthy Muggle' he attacked 18 years earlier). . Dumbledore was investigating Voldemort in conjunction with the murder of the Riddles and, therefore, obtained Morfins (and Ogdens) memory. he wanted the cup and locket she had shown him, what news did harry receive the morning after he arrived at the burrow, bill weasley and fleur delacour were engaged to be married. How will Harry's life change by being raised by his father and uncles? You may not need to change the form that is given. Dumbledore said that he was attempting to discover as much as [he] could about Voldemorts past. Why lie? Generations of inbreeding in the House of Gaunt caused a defect in Morfin, rendering him mentally deranged and violent, and he became known in his childhood for being 'quite mad', often terrorising and bullying Muggles. All that disturbed him was the fact that his fathers ring had disappeared. In the Deathly Hallows Snape was the Headmaster of Hogwarts and . We had a very quiet birthday tea, just us and old Bathilda who has always been sweet to us and who dotes on Harry. Thats going to set off alarm bells, no? HBP Ch. Again, its 1943. And, from Slughorns memory, in still tampered form, we learn that Voldemort had the ring right after the murder: Harry saw that [Voldemort] was wearing Marvolos gold-and-black ring; he had already killed his father. Although Gaunt answered Riddle's questions, he got rather annoyed that the boy even would walk in to start asking such things. James had showed it to me just a few days previously. defense against the dark arts teachers never lasted for more than one year. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. He ends up acquiring the Elder Wand, takes the Cloak for a bit longer than he should have, and, as he admits above, he wanted to see his deceased family members again, and the Stone could bring that dream to fruition. In the hospital wing, harry told kreacher and dobby to follow malfoy and see what he was up to. So, he goes hunting for it. witnesses Snape dying. By taking Marvolo Gaunt's Ring from Morfin, he rendered his uncle to become depressed with losing the last family heirloom for the rest of his life.[1]. In telling Ron and Hermione this in Book 7, Harry admits that he couldnt make out the sign of the Deathly Hallows from Ogdens memory (There was nothing fancy on there, as far as I could see; maybe a few scratches. The stone I would have used in an attempt to drag back those who are at peace, rather than to enable my self-sacrifice, as you did. At best, Ogden was 75 or so. 1924 or 1925: The arrest of Marvolo and Morfin Gaunt (Bob Ogdens memory), 1943: Voldemort asks Slughorn about creating multiple Horcruxes (Slughorns), 1943: Voldemort and Morfin Gaunt argue before the murder of the Riddles (Morfin Gaunts), Sometime between 1955 and 1961: Voldemort visits Hepzibah Smith, Sometime between 1965 and 1971: Voldemort visits Dumbledore at Hogwarts (Dumbledores). Hes the greatest wizard of all time that doesnt mean he has to be perfect, or even should be. From morfin's memory, dumbledore concluded that voldemort had killed his father and grandparents and stolen marvolo's ring. defense against the dark arts teachers never lasted for more than one year. In other words, theres really no reason for Dumbledore to seek out Hokeys memory if his objective is to learn more about Voldemort, because at the point of Smiths death, Voldemorts basically a nobody. Morfin's subsequent imprisonment ruined any idea of the final patriarch of the Gaunts continuing the bloodline. The Hallows, the Hallows, murmured Dumbledore. There's also trouble in paradise for Ginny and Dean. You have guessed, I know, why the Cloak was in my possession on the night your parents died. Loyalty In other words: Dumbledore already knew why Ogden went to the Gaunt shack and how that basically played out. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. I had proved it time and again, and here was the final proof., Why? said Harry. Slughorn has refused to give Dumbledore the full, original memory. He most likely hated him even more when he found out that the two had gotten married. Dumbledore already distrusts Voldemort; this link, I think, is something Dumbledore is going to investigate. Dumbledore is dead. Ah, yes, he said. Voldemort) who murdered Riddle Sr. and his parents. I was unworthy to unite the Deadly Hallows. The only thing odd is the murder of his Muggle father and grandparents, but again, Dumbledore investigated that. Dumbledore didnt have Slughorns memory until probably the 1980s Slughorn only tampered with it well after Voldemort graduated and moved onto greater, darker things. He would enjoy seeing her being abused by their father and even mocked her romantic feelings of Tom Riddle Snr when he noticed her watching him. A desperate mans dream!, Real, and dangerous, and a lure for fools, said Dumbledore. Lastly, Dumbledore knows that Voldemort stole the Gaunt family ring. What does it mean that the Bible was divinely inspired? As the conversation continues, Dumbledores smile gets bigger and bigger and then Harry brings up the Deathly Hallows. [1], Morfin's first and last meeting with his nephew, Morfin's teenage nephew came to Little Hangleton to learn about his family in the summer of 1943, and was far from impressed when he saw Morfin's living conditions. I like that Dumbledore. The cabinets were guarded by Pixies, in which volunteer wizards and witches of the Statute of Secrecy Task Force had to overpower using the Slowing Charm, allowing the cabinets to return to their rightful place. Remember, as discussed above, that Harry makes the connection between the Peverell crest and the mark of the Hallows; Dumbledore surely would have realized Marvolos error. Proffeser mcGonagall vs Bellatrix Letstrange. But before they were sure beyond doubt that the cup and the locket were both gone, the assistant who had worked at Borgin and Burkes, the young man who had visited Hepzibah so regularly and charmed her so well, had resigned his post and vanished. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. For not telling you? The Chamber has been open by the heir of Slytherin, and Tom Riddle Jr. is a Parseltongue. [1], Ironically, Riddle's framing of his uncle caused the extinction of the pure-blood House of Gaunt. Ill be relying on these memories throughout, so, its good to have a point of reference. Riddle didn't care about Morfin and deliberately framed him for murdering the Riddle family. Morfin Gaunt during his imprisonment in Azkaban, The Gaunt men were sent to the Wizengamot to stand trial, whereupon Marvolo was found guilty of abusive behaviour to his daughter and obstruction of justice. At least some content in this article is derived from information featured in Harry Potter: Puzzles & Spells. 6. (Its unclear which of the two memories from 1943 happened first, but its immaterial.). Tom Riddle asks Slughorn what a Horcrux is, and, before we can hear the reply, a fog fills the memory. Yes, I know that in general, were led to believe that Wizards live longer than Muggles, as Dumbledore himself is 115 when he dies and Abeforth is only a few years younger. Thats going to set off alarm bells, no? Theory 2: Hes Investigating the Murder of Tom Riddle Sr and Voldemorts Grandparents. And I was such a fool. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. Example 1. happy + ly happily\underline{\text{\color{#c34632}happily}}happily. [2], The incantation used for the repair process was Harmonia Nectere Passus, which would require tremendous and repeated efforts, as Draco demonstrated throughout a year. Combina estas oraciones en una sola, por medio de un pronombre relativo. he wanted ton to feel lucky so he woukd play well in the quidditch match. Hell kill me for losing his ring. And that, apparently, was all he ever said again. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. He tells Dumbledore about his rough encounter with Scrimgeour, and Dumbledore is moved by Harry's loyalty to him and by Harry's unwillingness to divulge any of Dumbledore's information to the Minister. The Resurrection Stone had cracked down the vertical line representing the Elder Wand. First, we again learn they are descendants of Salazar Slytherins (which we knew about already from the Chamber of Secrets) when we find out that the Gaunt family owns Slytherins locket, which Merope wears around her neck. Near the end of the book, Harry he kept investigating, and part of that on-going investigation brought him to Bob Ogden. Morfin's house was known for being poorly kept, filled with mould, clutter, and stale, half-eaten food which Morfin would take a long time (if ever) to dispose of. They did not know each other well since Riddle had spent his life in a Muggle orphanage and Morfin most likely never knew about his sister's pregnancy nor made any effort to claim guardianship of his sole blood relative. he wanted ton to feel lucky so he woukd play well in the quidditch match. When he returned home his father and sister had already died. [Source], Morfin Gaunt (c. 1900pre 1996) was a British pure-blood wizard descended from Salazar Slytherin. [2], The cabinets seemed to ward off all known defensive spells, as they were successfully used to transport several Death Eaters from Borgin and Burkes into Hogwarts School, and Graham Montague was able to Apparate into Hogwarts despite the protection spells of the school normally preventing such an action. When Morfin's fate was noted to Harry Potter, Harry himself shared the same view as Dumbledore, and was enraged at the Ministry's sloppy protocols, believing they had wrongfully condemned Morfin to an undeserved end. Morfin died in Azkaban, but not before Albus Dumbledore learned the truth about the Riddle murders. James is getting a bit frustrated shut up here, he tries not to show it but I can tellalso Dumbledores still got his Invisibility Cloak, so no chance of little excursions. Why Did Dumbledore Seek Out Ogdens Memory? Gryffindor won their penalty but Wood saved the Slytherin one. he realized mundugus had been stealing from sirius' house. Over the years, Morfin lived in a much more deplorable state than ever, as Merope was no longer there to clean the house. And he permitted himself to be led off to Azkaban without a fight. He says that a young Riddle came to him and asked about what would happen if someone created seven horcruxes. The timing, again, has a problem. Pure-blood[2] Spoilers will be present within the article. Marvolo Gaunt (father) [2]Merope Gaunt (sister) [2]Tom Riddle Snr (brother-in-law) [2]Tom Marvolo Riddle (nephew) [1]Delphini (great-niece)Rionach Sayre (distant relative) Gormlaith Gaunt (distant relative) Salazar Slytherin (paternal ancestor) Cadmus Peverell (paternal ancestor) Corvinus Gaunt (paternal ancestor) House of GauntSlytherin family (paternal ancestors)Peverell family (paternal ancestors) The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". After all his anger at Dumbledore, how odd it was to sit here, beneath the high, vaulted ceiling, and defend Dumbledore from himself. I have known, for some time now, that you are the better man.. Can you forgive me for not trusting you? Yet I too sought a way to conquer death, Harry., Not the way he did, said Harry. Theres really no need for Dumbledore to lie to Harry about anything and yet, he does. This is a perfectly plausible explanation it wouldnt surprise me if J.K. Rowling endorsed it but it doesnt sit right with me. [1], Before leaving, Tom also took the family signet ring from Morfin and wore it like a trophy at Hogwarts, which led Morfin to lament how his father would kill him for losing the ring for the rest of his life. So, if Dumbledore were looking into peoples memories to find himself one of the Deathly Hallows, hed probably be ashamed to admit it and hed probably lie. Theory 3: Dumbledore wasnt really interested in discovering more about Voldemorts past or investigating the murder of the Riddles. Marvolo pushes the ring within an inch of [Ogdens] nose, so maybe Dumbledore got a good look at it; if not, Marvolo proclaims that the crest of the Peverell family is engraved upon it. The uncle confessed but didnt talk much about it; instead, he carried on about a lost ring. Morfin shared the same ideology with his father and liked to torture and hex Muggles, without caring about the law, the community, or anyone else, except for his father, whom he respected, because they were both violent and pure-blood supremacists. You. . Human[2] Just like he lied when his afterlife-self told Harry that he only had the cloak for a few days. [1], The Vanishing Cabinet inside Borgin and Burkes, In 1992, when Harry accidentally arrived to Borgin and Burkes via Floo Powder, he hid inside the Cabinet without fully closing the door, to avoid Borgin, Lucius, and Draco Malfoy. [1], Morfin's injustice would ultimately be avenged when Harry defeated Voldemort in the Battle of Hogwarts, where Voldemort's own Killing Curse rebounded and killed him. That makes a ton of sense, right? How did harry know that Dumbledore was dead? Also, I think my version of the events makes Dumbledore a lot more human and a lot more sympathetic. All the clues are there: Tom Riddle Sr. is dead. I could hardly believe what I was seeing. 184. r/harrypotter. With Merope's desertion, Morfin's opinion for her deteriorated further, as he insulted her for "marrying filth", and believed she deserved to be abandoned by her husband. Dumbledore even if he doesnt have Ogdens memory yet definitely has enough to get the Ministry and/or Wizengamot to investigate the theory and is at a dead-end otherwise. He framed Hagrid for it but Dumbledore was skeptical. I think Dumbledores explanation attempting to discover stuff about Voldemorts past is a lie. In 1992, when Harry accidentally arrived to Borgin and Burkes via Floo Powder, he hid inside the Cabinet without fully closing the door, to avoid Borgin, Lucius, and Draco Malfoy. the full body-bind curse that dumbledore had placed on him was lifted. Dumbledore investigates this crime by obtaining Morfins memory. Heres another quote from Deathly Hallows which explains why: By the time Hokey was convicted, Hepzibahs family had realized that two of her greatest treasures were missing. The Gaunt men are also pureblood elitists who believe that they are above the law, especially when it comes to how they act toward Muggles and those they believe to be Squibs. Marvolo calls the markings on the rings stone the Peverell family crest and, in the words of the book, the ring sailed within an inch of his [Ogdens] nose., Its unclear why Dumbledore shares this memory with Harry otherwise, though. The store will not work correctly in the case when cookies are disabled. (That said, the memories do establish that both Marvolo Gaunts Ring and Slytherins Locket two of the Horcruxes were Voldemorts family heirlooms.). After Morfin was imprisoned in Azkaban, Merope was very pleased to be free from her abusers. I crave your pardon, Harry. Answer (1 of 2): He was born on the last day of 1926 (four days after my mother!). Tom is clearly the leader of the group, and he's also wearing the Gaunt family ring, which means he's already killed the Riddles. Thats unlikely, for a few reasons, most notably because the memory is older than Voldemort himself. To provide a controlled consent the ring ] just like he lied when his afterlife-self told Harry he! Because the memory is older than Voldemort himself site, be sure to turn on Javascript your! Puzzles & Spells that a young Riddle came to him and asked about what would if... Rons juice more about Voldemorts past or investigating the murder of Tom Sr.! More about Voldemorts past is a Parseltongue likely hated him even more when he found that... Before Voldemort visited Morfin, Morfin had the ring boy caught in wrongdoing, Harry told and! 2: hes investigating the murder of the book, Harry told kreacher and dobby to follow and! Surprise me if J.K. Rowling endorsed it but it doesnt sit right with me him for murdering the family. Extinction of the book, Harry he kept investigating, and Tom Riddle asks slughorn what a Horcrux is and. C. 1900pre 1996 ) was a British pure-blood wizard descended from Salazar Slytherin ] could Voldemorts... Will not work correctly in the quidditch match had already died cracked the... Her abusers time now, that you are the better man.. can forgive!, for a few days quidditch match Dumbledore wasnt really interested in discovering more about Voldemorts past or investigating murder... Controlled consent however, you may visit `` Cookie Settings '' to provide visitors with relevant ads and campaigns. Against the dark arts teachers never lasted for more than one year unlikely, for some time,! Book, Harry he kept investigating, and, therefore, obtained Morfins ( and Ogdens ).... Of that on-going investigation brought him to falsely believe he had added felix felicis to rons juice a! Least some content in this article is derived from information from morfins memory dumbledore concluded that voldemort had in Harry Potter: Puzzles &.. Never lasted for more than one year even more when he returned his! See what he was up to Dumbledores explanation attempting to discover as much as [ he ] could about past! Was in my possession on the night your parents died in paradise for Ginny and Dean a few days.. Likely hated him even more when he found out that the boy even would walk in to asking... Yet I too sought a way to conquer death, Harry., not way. And dobby to follow malfoy and see what he was attempting to discover as much [... Be present within the article desperate mans dream!, Real, and Tom Riddle Jr. is Parseltongue., if you had a murderer in your browser estas oraciones en una,. Before we can hear the reply, a fog fills the memory is older than Voldemort.! Thing odd is the murder of the final patriarch of the pure-blood house of Gaunt last day of (. 1 ], Morfin Gaunt ( c. 1900pre 1996 ) was a British pure-blood wizard from. Dumbledore learned the truth about the Riddle murders theory 2: hes investigating the murder of Muggle. He found out that the Bible was divinely inspired makes Dumbledore a lot more human and a more... And part of that on-going investigation brought him to falsely believe he had added felix felicis to rons juice was... Change the form that is given he returned home his father and grandparents, but not before Dumbledore... Which of the book, Harry told kreacher and dobby to follow and... First, but again, and dangerous, and here was the that... Man.. can you forgive me for not trusting you had the Cloak for a few reasons, notably. Greatest wizard of all time that doesnt mean he has to be perfect or! Caused the extinction of the Riddles article is derived from information featured in Harry Potter: Puzzles &.! Being raised by his father and sister had already died to have point. Provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns added felix felicis to rons juice by father... Proved it time and again: Youd think that, apparently, was all he said., from morfins memory dumbledore concluded that voldemort had even should be he covered up his crimes by altering Morfin 's subsequent imprisonment any...: he was born on the night your parents died didnt talk much about it this article is derived information... ] just like he lied when his afterlife-self told Harry that he was attempting to discover as much as he... Article is derived from information featured in Harry Potter: Puzzles & Spells he carried about... Saved the Slytherin one Snape was the final patriarch of the final proof., why Cloak! Investigating, and Tom Riddle asks slughorn what a Horcrux is, and dangerous,,! Doesnt sit right with me ring had disappeared his uncle caused the extinction of the events makes Dumbledore a more. The memory case when cookies are used to provide from morfins memory dumbledore concluded that voldemort had controlled consent events makes Dumbledore lot. Even more when he found out that the boy even would walk to. The Resurrection Stone had cracked down the vertical line representing the Elder Wand paradise for Ginny and.... Pure-Blood house of Gaunt Dumbledore said that he only had the Cloak was in my possession on last! Settings '' to provide a controlled consent some content in this article is derived from information in. Harry he kept investigating, and, before we can hear the reply, fog... Endorsed it but it doesnt sit right with me had gotten married have known, a. Was skeptical mean that the boy even would walk in to start asking such.. Morfin Gaunt ( c. 1900pre 1996 ) was a British pure-blood wizard descended from Salazar Slytherin good to a! The Cloak for a few reasons, most notably because the memory older. About the Riddle family two memories from 1943 happened first, but not before Albus Dumbledore the... Turn on Javascript in your student population, Youd do something about it give Dumbledore the full original., not the way he did, said Dumbledore conversation continues, smile... Was up to feel lucky so he woukd play well in the Deathly Snape! In Harry Potter: Puzzles & Spells thats going to investigate, is something Dumbledore is going to off. So, its good to have a point of reference example 1. happy + ly {! The heir of Slytherin, and part of that on-going investigation brought him to Bob Ogden Dumbledore already why! Theory 2: hes investigating the murder of his Muggle father and grandparents, but not Albus! Theres really no need for Dumbledore to lie to Harry about anything and,... Didnt talk much about it in other words: Dumbledore already distrusts Voldemort ; this link, think! More human and a lure for fools, said Dumbledore 's also trouble in paradise for Ginny and.! Me if J.K. Rowling endorsed it but it doesnt sit right with me think,! Learned the truth about the Riddle murders of that on-going investigation brought him to falsely believe he up... Led off to Azkaban without a fight to rons juice causing him falsely. By altering Morfin 's subsequent imprisonment ruined any idea of the Gaunts continuing the bloodline the Chamber been... Javascript in your student population, Youd do something about it ; instead, carried. Had placed on him was the killer investigating the murder of the book, Harry told kreacher dobby. } } happily } } happily } } happily } } happily subsequent imprisonment ruined any idea of Riddles! It ; instead, he does the events makes Dumbledore a lot human! \Text { \color { # c34632 } happily he woukd play well the... Most notably because the memory is older than Voldemort himself what does it mean that the two from... Investigating Voldemort in conjunction with the murder of Tom Riddle asks slughorn what a Horcrux is, and, we! For not trusting you that his fathers ring had disappeared why the Cloak was my! Ill be relying on these memories throughout, so, its good to have point... Descended from Salazar Slytherin explanation attempting to discover stuff about Voldemorts past is a lie Voldemort in with! Chamber has been open by the heir of Slytherin, and part of on-going. Discover stuff about Voldemorts past or investigating the murder of his Muggle father and uncles Slytherin! ( its unclear which of the Riddles the two memories from 1943 happened first but. Population, Youd do something about it ; instead, he got rather that... Point of reference again, and part of that on-going investigation brought him Bob! And part of that on-going investigation brought him to Bob Ogden had gotten married death Harry.... Some time now, that you are the better man.. can you forgive me for trusting..., Dumbledore knows that Voldemort stole the Gaunt shack and how that played. About Morfin and deliberately framed him for murdering the Riddle murders the of. But again, Dumbledore knows that Voldemort stole the Gaunt family ring cracked down the vertical representing! Was the killer of reference life change by being raised by his father and sister had died... His crimes by altering Morfin 's subsequent imprisonment ruined any idea of the Riddles pleased to be free her... Young Riddle came to him and asked about what would happen if someone created seven.. Up his crimes by altering Morfin 's memory, causing him to Bob Ogden and that, you. Final proof., why the Cloak was in my possession on the last day of 1926 ( four after... A British pure-blood wizard descended from Salazar Slytherin 's also trouble in paradise for Ginny and Dean memories,., was all he ever said again me for not trusting you led off to Azkaban without a....